- I Can’t Hear You / Matthew West
- I Could Be Wrong / Lit
- I Don’t Want to Be / Gavin DeGraw
- If the World Was Ending / JP Saxe, Julia Michaels
- If You’re Gone / Matchbox Twenty
- I Hate This / Tenille Arts
- I’ll Be / Edwin McCain
- I’ll Be There for You / The Rembrandts
- I’ll Fly Away / Jars of Clay
- I Melt With You / Modern English
- I’m Gonna Be (500 Miles) / The Proclaimers
- I’m Not Who I Was / Brandon Heath
- I’m Your Man / Michael Buble
- I’m Yours / Jason Mraz
- Independence Day / Martina McBride
- I Need a Dollar / Aloe Blacc
- In My Blood / Shawn Mendes
- In Too Deep / Sum 41
- Iris / Goo Goo Dolls
- I Sure Can Smell the Rain / BlackHawk
- It’s a Beautiful Day / Michael Buble
- It’s Not Me, It’s You / Skillet
- It’s Time / Imagine Dragons
- I’ve Been Everywhere / Johnny Cash
- I Wanna Talk About Me / Toby Keith
- I will Survive / Me First and the Gimme Gimmes
- I Will Wait / Mumford & Sons
- I Wish I Was / The Avett Brothers
Lists of All the Things You've Never Wondered About
